Omega Chi and Kappa Tau both organize respective date nights. When Cappie sees Rusty stressed about getting a date for the social, he realizes it's because Rusty is a virgin and sets him up with the campus door knob, Lisa Lawson. Despite her plan to turn things around with Evan during date night, Casey is unable to sit still when she hears this news and goes to the Kappa Tau house to save Rusty from making a big mistake ... as we find out Cappie was Casey's first.